Prendre Vs ApporterA2
Vous allez enfin choisir entre prendre et apporter selon le point de vue du déplacement. Entrez dans la première unité pour parler des objets, des personnes et des lieux avec plus de précision.
What translations are available?
Same idea of transport
Prendre and apporter can both refer to transport, but they do not emphasize the same thing. With one, the focus is on the action of taking something with oneself. With the other, the focus is on bringing something to a person or a place. So one can say I take my coat to talk about the object one takes along, and I bring my coat to your place to talk about the movement toward the intended destination. When it concerns a person, prendre can also mean accompanying or taking them along.
Point-of-view rule
The choice depends on the point of reference. Prendre starts from the place or person who already has the object and makes it leave. Apporter starts from the person who transports it and makes the object arrive at the point of reference. One says I take the file from the office if the file leaves the office with me. One says I bring the file to the office if the file arrives at the office through my intervention. The same object can therefore take two different verbs depending on the direction of the movement.
| Idea | |
|---|---|
A Textbook Cannot Hear You
Loco can. Say something and find out.
Prendre your bag or apporter it
With a personal object, compare the place of departure and the place of arrival. Take your bag is appropriate if the person must pick it up in order to leave with it. Bring your bag is appropriate if they must bring it to the person speaking or to another specific place. In take your bag and come, the bag accompanies the person who is moving. In bring your bag to the kitchen, the bag must end up in the kitchen. The verb changes as soon as the point of arrival changes.
| Usage | Explanation | |
|---|---|---|
| We choose prendre when the object accompanies someone who leaves the place where we are. | ||
| We choose apporter when the object is brought toward the person speaking or toward the place of arrival. |
Talking about a person
For a person, prendre is commonly used to say that one takes them somewhere. One says I pick up the children at school or he took his sister to the doctor. Apporter is not normally used for a person in this sense. In informal language, one may hear he brought us to the train station in playful or regional expressions, but standard usage prefers to take, to drive or prendre. For a person, prendre therefore remains the usual verb when it involves transporting or accompanying them.
| Usage | Explanation | |
|---|---|---|
| We use prendre to say that we accompany or take someone from one place to another. | ||
| We use apporter with a person only in a familiar or affectionate style. |
Prendre for other actions
Prendre also has very common meanings that have nothing to do with transport to a place. It can mean grasping something, as in to take a pen. It can mean consuming, as in to have a coffee, or using, as in to take a shower. It is also used to mean borrowing or choosing, as in to take a book from the library and to take the 8 a.m. train. This verb is therefore very broad, and the context shows which meaning should be understood.
| Word | Definition | |
|---|---|---|
| Catch with the hand or another means of grasping. | ||
| Drink or eat something. | ||
| Employ something for a specific action. | ||
| Receive something for a limited time with the intention of returning it. | ||
| Get hold of something that is moving or that one is looking for. | ||
| Obtain something that is given or offered to you. | ||
| Accept a situation or a remark without reacting too much. | ||
| Start to do something in a specific context. | ||
| Choose an attitude or a way of acting. | ||
| Choose in advance a seat, a ticket, or a service. |
Train Your Ear as Well
Hear the language at full speed, then answer it.
Apporter emphasizes arrival
Apporter puts the object and its arrival at the intended point in the foreground. One says I bring cakes to the birthday party because the cakes go all the way to the party. One says she brought the keys to the neighbor because the keys arrive at the neighbor’s place. The verb is very often used with a complement introduced by to or with a specific place. It is appropriate when the main idea is to get something to someone, a table, an office or a given place.
| Usage | Explanation | |
|---|---|---|
| We use apporter to emphasize that the object arrives with a recipient or at a specific place. | ||
| We use apporter when we want to emphasize that we provide something to a person. | ||
| We can also use apporter to show that an action produces a useful effect. |
Informal and regional uses
In some informal or regional usages, apporter may appear where one would expect another verb of movement. In Canada, one often hears to bring someone by car to mean driving them somewhere. In standard French usage, to take or to drive is generally preferred for a person. With objects, normal usage remains the same everywhere: apporter is used to bring something toward a place or toward someone. Broader uses are understood thanks to the context, but they do not replace standard usage.
Take the Quiz!
Vous pouvez maintenant repérer si l’on insiste sur le départ avec prendre ou sur l’arrivée avec apporter, et choisir le verbe juste selon le contexte. Continuez à pratiquer avec des phrases de la vie quotidienne pour rendre ce réflexe naturel.