❓

vs 什么 shénme —— 哪个 vs 什么

本模块比较中文中的“哪”、

核心对比

“哪”用来提问“哪个”或“哪一类”,通常后面接名词或量词短语。“什么”用来提问事物的本体、内容或性质,常单独使用或接名词。“哪个”相当于“哪”加“个”,多指在有限选项中问“哪一个”。三者的区别在于提问的范围和结构。

'Which' is used to ask 'which one' or 'which type', usually followed by a noun or a measure-word phrase. 'What' is used to ask about the object, content, or nature of something, often used alone or followed by a noun. 'Which' (as in which one) corresponds to 'which' plus a classifier, and tends to ask 'which one' among a limited set. The differences among the three lie in the scope and structure of the question.

规则
🇬🇧 English
Rule
例句
🇬🇧 English
Examples
“哪”后面接名词,问类别或单位。
'Which' is followed by a noun to ask about a category or unit.
📚你喜欢哪本书?
Which book do you like? 📚
“什么”问内容或本体,可以单独提问。
'What' asks about content or essence, and can be asked alone.
👀你在看什么?
What are you watching? 👀
“哪个”强调“哪一个”,常指有限选项。
'Which' emphasizes 'which one', often referring to a limited set.
👉哪个是你的?
Which one is yours? 👉

“哪”的用法

“哪”常用作疑问代词,后面接名词表示“哪一类”,接量词短语表示“哪一个”。在口语中,“哪+名词”比“什么+名词”更像在选类别而不是询问本体。“哪”也可以出现在“哪里”“哪儿”等词内,表示地点。

'Which' is commonly used as an interrogative pronoun, followed by a noun to indicate 'which category/type', and followed by a measure-word phrase to indicate 'which one'. In spoken language, '哪+ noun' tends to feel more like selecting a category rather than asking about the essence. 'Which' can also appear in words such as '哪里' or '哪儿' to express location.

词组
🇬🇧 English
Phrase
定义
🇬🇧 English
Definition
例句
🇬🇧 English
Examples
📚哪本书
哪本书📚
问具体是哪一类或哪一项。
Asks specifically which category or item.
你想借哪本书?
Which book would you like to borrow? 📚
☕️哪种咖啡
哪种咖啡☕️
问类别。
Asks for category.
你喜欢哪种咖啡?
Which kind of coffee do you like?
📅哪一天
哪一天📅
问在选项中的某一天。
Asks for a day among options.
你哪一天有空?
Which day are you free?
🌏哪里
哪里🌏
问地点。
Asks for location.
你住在哪里?
Where do you live?

“什么”的用法

“什么”是通用疑问代词,提问未知的事物、内容、理由或性质。“什么”可以直接作宾语,也可以和名词连用表示“哪种东西”但语义偏向本体而非选项。在对话中,“什么”常用于开放性提问,不假定有限选项。

'What' is a general interrogative pronoun used to ask about unknown things, content, reasons, or properties. 'What' can function directly as an object, or be combined with a noun to express 'which kind of thing', though the meaning leans toward the entity rather than an option. In conversation, 'what' is often used for open-ended questions, not assuming limited options.

词组
🇬🇧 English
Phrase
定义
🇬🇧 English
Definition
例句
🇬🇧 English
Examples
📦什么
什么📦
问事物或内容。
Asks about objects or content.
你在想什么?
What are you thinking?
🗞️什么事情
什么事情🗞️
问具体内容。
Asks for specifics.
你有什么事情?
What do you have going on?
🎨什么颜色
什么颜色🎨
问性质或属性。
Asks about properties or attributes.
你喜欢什么颜色?
What color do you like?
🔊什么声音
什么声音🔊
问来源或内容。
Asks about source or content.
外面有什么声音?
What sound is there outside?

“哪个”的用法

“哪个”通常用于在已知或有限的选项中选择一项,相当于英文的“which one”。“哪个”后可直接加名词,句子语境里往往隐含一组可选对象。“哪个”比“哪+名词”更突出“一个”的选择感,常见于指物或人。

'Which' is typically used to select one item from known or limited options, equivalent to English 'which one'. After '哪个', a noun can follow directly; the context often implies a set of selectable objects. 'Which' places more emphasis on selecting one among a set than '哪+noun', commonly used for objects or people.

词组
🇬🇧 English
Phrase
定义
🇬🇧 English
Definition
例句
🇬🇧 English
Examples
🥤哪个杯子
哪个杯子🥤
在杯子中选一个。
Choose one among cups.
哪个杯子是你的?
Which cup is yours?
🧑哪个人
哪个人🧑
在一群人中选一个。
Choose one among a group.
你说的是哪个人?
Which person are you talking about?
✅哪个答案
哪个答案✅
在答案中选一个。
Choose one among the answers.
哪个答案对?
Which answer is correct?
🚪哪个房间
哪个房间🚪
在房间中选一个。
Choose one among rooms.
你住在哪个房间?
Which room do you live in?

提问范围

使用“哪”时,提问者通常假设有分类或选项,哪怕没有明确列出。使用“什么”时,提问者不限定范围,期望对方给出内容本身。使用“哪个”时,提问者假定在一组成员中选择一个。选择合适的词可以让问题更清晰。

When using '哪', the questioner typically assumes the existence of a category or option, even if not explicitly listed. When using '什么', the questioner does not limit the range and expects the content itself. When using '哪个', the questioner assumes selecting one from a group. Choosing the right word can make the question clearer.

规则
🇬🇧 English
Rule
例句
🇬🇧 English
Examples
“哪”隐含类别或单位的选择。
'哪' implies selecting from a category or unit.
🏪你常去哪家店?
Which store do you usually go to? 🏪
“什么”不限定选项,询问内容。
'什么' does not limit options, asks for content.
🔍你在找什么?
What are you looking for? 🔍
“哪个”限定在一组中选一项。
'哪个' limits to selecting one item within a group.
📚三本里你想要哪个?
Which of the three would you like? 📚

结构位置

“哪”通常出现在“哪+量词+名词”或“哪+名词”结构中。“什么”可以作主语、宾语或定语,常见于“什么+名词”。“哪个”常作定语修饰名词,也可在问句中作主语或宾语。正确选择结构有助于表达明确的疑问。

'Which' typically appears in the '哪+measure word+noun' or '哪+noun' structures. 'What' can function as a subject, object, or modifier, commonly seen in '什么+noun'. 'Which' often acts as a determiner modifying a noun, and can also serve as a subject or object in questions. Properly choosing the structure helps express a clear question.

结构
🇬🇧 English
Structure
定义
🇬🇧 English
Definition
例句
🇬🇧 English
Examples
哪+名词
哪+名词
类别性提问。
Category-type question.
你属于哪组?
Which group do you belong to?
哪+量词+名词
哪+量词+名词
单位性或选项性提问。
Unit or option-type question.
你喜欢哪一种?
Which one do you like?
什么+名词
什么+名词
内容或性质提问。
Content or property question.
这是什么东西?
What is this thing?
哪个+名词
哪个+名词
在一组中选一项。
Select one item in a group.
你认识哪个老师?
Which teacher do you know?

语境选择

在需要对选项做选择时,优先用“哪个”或“哪+量词”。在询问信息本身时,优先用“什么”。在分类或常规类别间提问时,常用“哪+名词”。判断语境的关键是你是否在让对方从一组中选“一个”,还是让对方说明“是什么”。

When you need to choose among options, prefer '哪个' or '哪+量词'. When asking about the information itself, prefer '什么'. When asking about a category or general class, commonly use '哪+名词'. The key to judging the context is whether you are asking the other person to pick 'one' from a set, or to explain 'what it is'.

规则
🇬🇧 English
Rule
例句
🇬🇧 English
Examples
需要选“一项”时用“哪个”。
Need to choose one item; use '哪个'.
🕑两个时间段,哪个方便?
Two time slots, which one is convenient? 🕑
需要选类别时用“哪+名词”。
Need to choose by category; use '哪+名词'.
🎓你毕业于哪所大学?
Which university did you graduate from? 🎓
需要内容本身时用“什么”。
Need the content itself; use '什么'.
🗨️你刚才说的是什么意思?
What did you just say? 🗨️

对照练习

下列表对比相近结构的语义差别:“哪本书”通常假定有备选书目,“什么书”更偏向询问书的类型或内容。“哪家饭馆”多半在已知饭馆中选择,“什么饭馆”更像在问饭馆的性质或种类。“哪个人”是在一群人里选,“什么人”是在问人的类型或特征。

The following items compare similar structures and their semantic differences: 'which book' usually presupposes a set of books, while 'what book' leans toward asking about the type or content of a book. 'which restaurant' often selects among known restaurants, while 'what restaurant' asks about the restaurant's nature or kind. 'which person' selects within a group, while 'what person' asks about the type or features of a person.

词组
🇬🇧 English
Phrase
定义
🇬🇧 English
Definition
例句
🇬🇧 English
Examples
📚哪本书
哪本书📚
在书中选一类或一本。
Choose a category or one book.
明天带哪本书?
Tomorrow which book should I bring?
📖什么书
什么书📖
问书的类型或内容。
Ask for type or content of a book.
你喜欢看什么书?
What kind of books do you like to read?
🍜哪家饭馆
哪家饭馆🍜
在饭馆中选一家。
Choose a restaurant among known ones.
我们去哪家饭馆?
Which restaurant should we go to?
🥢什么饭馆
什么饭馆🥢
问饭馆的种类或特色。
Ask about the type or features of a restaurant.
那是什么饭馆?
What kind of restaurant is that?
🧑‍🎓哪个人
哪个人🧑‍🎓
在一群人中选一个。
Choose one person from a group.
班里哪个人最早到?
Which person in the class arrived first?
👤什么人
什么人👤
问人的类型或身份。
Ask about type or identity of a person.
他是什么人?
What kind of person is he?

小结

“哪”偏向类别或单位的选择,常接名词或量词短语。“什么”提问内容本身,适合开放性信息询问。“哪个”强调在选项中选一项,通常对应“which one”。根据提问的范围和目标选择合适的疑问词,可以让表达更自然准确。

'Which' tends to select by category or unit and is often followed by a noun or measure word phrase. 'What' asks about the content itself, suitable for open-ended information inquiries. 'Which' emphasizes selecting one from a set, usually corresponding to 'which one'. Choose the appropriate question word according to the scope and goal of the question to make the expression more natural and accurate.